Today, we delve into the technicalities of hydraulic cement and crystalline cement versus polyurethane grout for leak seal injection. This article aims to provide you with detailed, actionable information to guide your decision-making process.

Understanding Your Options

Hydraulic cement, crystalline cement, and polyurethane grout are not competing product categories. Instead, they each offer unique benefits and applications. Hydraulic cement and crystalline cement are cost-effective and easy to apply, making them a go-to solution for many common situations. They share similar properties with basic cement repair, providing a reliable solution for static structures.

However, let’s be clear. If your crack or joint is subject to any significant movement, hydraulic and crystalline cement may fail over time, just like common cement. Yes, crystalline cement does expand over time and fill cracks, but it’s not designed to handle excessive movement. (This fact is actually listed on crystalline cement manufacturer technical data sheets.)

When to Use Polyurethane Grout

Polyurethane grout is the appropriate choice when a structure is subject to movement over time. It’s a more complex and costly solution (in the short term) than simply using hydraulic cement, but worth the investment in the long term.

Consider a three-foot thick potable water tank filled with rebar. You might have a hairline crack - a minor weeper - held together by the rebar. You could easily seal this with hydraulic or crystalline cement, and the leak would stop for the short term. But remember, you still have three feet of water in your concrete, and your rebar is potentially exposed to that.

In such a case, full-depth injection using a polyurethane grout would be highly beneficial. This product has characteristics that hydraulic cement doesn’t have, making it a more reliable solution for dynamic structures.

The Issue of Movement

Movement is the biggest challenge when using hydraulic cement. In manholes, for instance, you’ll often see pipe invert laterals coated with hydraulic cement to stop leaks. But the leaks return year after year, requiring more and more cement.

Why not choose a more lasting solution? Use a urethane once, spend a little more, and have a flexible product in place. You won’t ever have to do it again. It’s simple, and it’s long-lasting.

Final Thoughts

Let’s address a common scenario. Parking garages often operate on tight budgets. When faced with the cost of injecting all the cracks, the owner may not have the entire budget at the moment - but still need to stop the leaks. In such cases, we recommend starting with hydraulic cement or crystalline cement to stop the leak on a short-term basis - but also start saving/budgeting for a permanent polyurethane crack injection solution.

Remember, leaks may return due to structural movement caused by thermal cycles or expansive soil swelling. When they do, you’ll need to address them. By providing a quick solution now and helping plan for the future, we build trust with our clients. Many buildings and parking garages set up remedial grouting programs to address long-term problems periodically.

Contact us for more information on the best grouting solutions for your specific needs. We are committed to providing you with reliable, professional, and detailed information to guide your decisions. Remember, the choice of materials is paramount, and we are here to help you make the best choice.

Want more info on polyurethane leak seal grout and equipment?